VLDC9 - vanilla level design contest 9
Re: VLDC9 - vespertine lyrebirds detecting chapeaus 9
So why wasn't the double sprite glitch patched out like in JUMP?
this is getting laundromatic
- morsel/morceau
- Posts: 401
- Joined: 14 years ago
- Location: exotic horse island
Re: VLDC9 - vespertine lyrebirds detecting chapeaus 9
^The compiler didn't think to add it (you can't think of everything). It's still the level designer's fault. If you play your level you should notice this happens and either request the patch or change the obstacle.
I thought the satellite was supposed to be Earth too, but what land masses are represented? Not North and South America, because they're round the wrong way (e: of course!). Perhaps an alternate reality world where New Zealand occupies an entire hemisphere.
I thought the satellite was supposed to be Earth too, but what land masses are represented? Not North and South America, because they're round the wrong way (e: of course!). Perhaps an alternate reality world where New Zealand occupies an entire hemisphere.
dont wanna jihad no more
Re: VLDC9 - vespertine lyrebirds detecting chapeaus 9
Ah, the ol' "If you take into account the constraints of vanilla and squint a whole bunch, it might pass as this recognizable thing for most viewers". I respect it.
Re: VLDC9 - vespertine lyrebirds detecting chapeaus 9
It was simply overlooked. The double spike set-up seems to be the most common occurrence of it, and I think this is the only level that really uses that gimmick to any degree - or at least, I can't recall any others, so it was pretty easy to miss.Ryrir wrote:So why wasn't the double sprite glitch patched out like in JUMP?
The patch was one of the first ones added to the list for the next VLDC though, so it'll be fixed there.
also: one level video warning tomorrow (most likely)
- Mata Hari
- Posts: 2523
- Joined: 14 years ago
- https://matahari.talkhaus.com/
Re: VLDC9 - vespertine lyrebirds detecting chapeaus 9
Reminds me of the Atari water from RTTC. Those were... days, of some kind.Ometeotl wrote:Ah, the ol' "If you take into account the constraints of vanilla and squint a whole bunch, it might pass as this recognizable thing for most viewers". I respect it.
- Ivy
- Posts: 2389
- Joined: 10 years ago
- Pronouns: any
- Contact:
- https://ivy.talkhaus.com/
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
If that's Earth why does it slither in from the top of the screen for a few seconds on the overworld?
3DS FC: 2793-0650-7690 | Switch: SW-2766-9108-9399 | Steam: ivysaur1996 (ivy)
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
I still don't think tomorrow's level is that hard. And if it's a one level video, it's gonna be a short one too... level that follows it is pretty nice. Guess that's worth mentioning!
50th: STORMCLOUD CITADEL by Roykirbs
74th: MOON TEMPLE by msi810
Roykirbs kind of dropped a lot - he got 2nd place in VLDC8!
And eh, I guess I like Moon Temple a bit more than a 37. Second half is not that bad besides some stuff that's hard to anticipate.
Also, while the double-sprite glitch seems negative during most of the second half, that setup where the thwimp jumps on 1F0 while you're spinning on spikes seems to take advantage of it?
50th: STORMCLOUD CITADEL by Roykirbs
74th: MOON TEMPLE by msi810
Roykirbs kind of dropped a lot - he got 2nd place in VLDC8!
And eh, I guess I like Moon Temple a bit more than a 37. Second half is not that bad besides some stuff that's hard to anticipate.
Also, while the double-sprite glitch seems negative during most of the second half, that setup where the thwimp jumps on 1F0 while you're spinning on spikes seems to take advantage of it?
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
I'm not sure that I liked the way that yellow pipe was hidden as much as other people did. I was usually big when I went down there (it is hidden in a rather out of the way place to boot) and it looked like decoration to me, especially since there are other yellow pipes used as decoration in this level. This Dragon Coin sticks out as being really hard to find when compared to the others. I can actually knock this level for Dragon Coin placement too, as the Dragon Coins are necessary to get the secret exit. Speaking of the secret exit, there really needed to be some indication that it was related to the Dragon Coins, as players not playing the compilation have no apparent incentive to get those.
As it stands, in order to get the secret exit, it felt like I needed to jump in a gap that looked like a hole and go in a pipe that looked like decoration in order to accomplish the seemingly unrelated task of getting the Dragon Coins. Now this is what a puzzle that "lacks clarity" looks like IMO. >.>
Secret exit aside, the level played alright for a castley romp level. I liked some of the platforming with the lasers in the second half, but I wish there were more obstacles like the one for the Dragon Coin around there.
The second level had some neat ideas for obstacles, but the difficulty curve was very janky. From one obstacle to the next, the difficulty in succeeding the obstacle and the punishment for failing it were all over the place. I liked the bone fish walls though. The (presumably Earth) planet in the background looked goofy as well, but it made me smile. :) There was also the double sprite glitch to contend with. Honestly, I prefer stuff like this not being patched out so we experience the level with the flaws that the judges had to.
As it stands, in order to get the secret exit, it felt like I needed to jump in a gap that looked like a hole and go in a pipe that looked like decoration in order to accomplish the seemingly unrelated task of getting the Dragon Coins. Now this is what a puzzle that "lacks clarity" looks like IMO. >.>
Secret exit aside, the level played alright for a castley romp level. I liked some of the platforming with the lasers in the second half, but I wish there were more obstacles like the one for the Dragon Coin around there.
The second level had some neat ideas for obstacles, but the difficulty curve was very janky. From one obstacle to the next, the difficulty in succeeding the obstacle and the punishment for failing it were all over the place. I liked the bone fish walls though. The (presumably Earth) planet in the background looked goofy as well, but it made me smile. :) There was also the double sprite glitch to contend with. Honestly, I prefer stuff like this not being patched out so we experience the level with the flaws that the judges had to.
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
Ironically enough, the compilation made that first level's secret exit EASIER to get- the reason you needed all of them at first was because that makes them all not come back, but the compilation does that automatically when you get the midpoint or clear the level. So, now all you have to do is get that one specific Yoshi Coin, clear the level, and now the door appears. But that doesn't really make it any better...Lockirby2 wrote:I'm not sure that I liked the way that yellow pipe was hidden as much as other people did. I was usually big when I went down there (it is hidden in a rather out of the way place to boot) and it looked like decoration to me, especially since there are other yellow pipes used as decoration in this level. This Dragon Coin sticks out as being really hard to find when compared to the others. I can actually knock this level for Dragon Coin placement too, as the Dragon Coins are necessary to get the secret exit. Speaking of the secret exit, there really needed to be some indication that it was related to the Dragon Coins, as players not playing the compilation have no apparent incentive to get those.
As it stands, in order to get the secret exit, it felt like I needed to jump in a gap that looked like a hole and go in a pipe that looked like decoration in order to accomplish the seemingly unrelated task of getting the Dragon Coins. Now this is what a puzzle that "lacks clarity" looks like IMO. >.>
Secret exit aside, the level played alright for a castley romp level. I liked some of the platforming with the lasers in the second half, but I wish there were more obstacles like the one for the Dragon Coin around there.
The second level had some neat ideas for obstacles, but the difficulty curve was very janky. From one obstacle to the next, the difficulty in succeeding the obstacle and the punishment for failing it were all over the place. I liked the bone fish walls though. The (presumably Earth) planet in the background looked goofy as well, but it made me smile. :) There was also the double sprite glitch to contend with. Honestly, I prefer stuff like this not being patched out so we experience the level with the flaws that the judges had to.
- TaviTurnip
- Reach for the top
- Abministrator
- Posts: 1077
- Joined: 14 years ago
- First name: Rena
- Location: Winter
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
91st, though...
I regularly stream on Twitch! with other members of the talkhaus. Come watch Monday, Tuesday and Friday at 2PM for blind playthroughs and Pokémon and Touhou and stuff. Come hang out with us!
- Zephyr_DragonLord
- The dragon awakens...!
- Posts: 1047
- Joined: 8 years ago
- First name: Zach
- Location: Somewhere between dreams and dormancy
Re: VLDC9 - vigilant leviathans dedicated craters 9
It deserved worse.TaviTurnip wrote:91st, though...
Anyways, the two other levels from yesterday, and then I'll get to why I hate it so.
Stormcloud Citadel is a level that had the potential to be really amazing, but just misbalanced the sections. The sections with the light should have been longer, as they were some of the most unique parts of this level. That tiny pipe should have been somewhere where you didn't have to take a blind jump. This level doesn't really seem like an exploratory level, but it goes ahead and does it anyways. This hurts it. But despite all that, the music is good, and the obstacles are interesting. Not as solid as last time, but still a good showing.
Moon Temple has some really cool ideas, too. It's rather difficult, but I think I'd enjoy these spinjumping puzzles. I don't know what's up with the differences between the first and second halves, but I like that second part more, even if it is more difficult. The double sprite glitch is pretty sad here, but it can be worked around... Waiting for bonefish is just a flawed idea in general, but this does several aspects of good levels well, so good job.
As for Moontop Metonymy, it deserves Worst World. It's the only overworld level so far that I feel actually deserves it. The first problem is that fugly cloud... I can see why raocow likes the concept, but that's left for a far better level using custom graphics. Secondly, and most importantly... there isn't an easy way to speed up the cloud. This is far and away the biggest problem of the level, and it makes the bullet bill death chambers and the very beginning pretty dismal to play through. This is like one of those strange NES games; the controls are finicky, and the gameplay doesn't really justify that awkwardness. If the cloud controlled better, I would be far easier on this level. As it is... it's not great. You made a good effort, but cloud levels are not the place for hectic gameplay on the base game. At least it tries to explain it to you, which is a plus...
I am prone to almost everything... except spontaneous violence.
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
(It was about time)
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
raocow wrote:I know there is a population on Earth. They like to populate. I like to gesticulate. We're friends!
(It was about time)
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
91st: MOONTOP METONYMY by Daizo Dee Von
I personally don't think this level is even close to the worst ones. It wasn't even in my green doors list (which is why it has only been added in the update, and I heard the door doesn't actually work? lol)
EDIT: uhh, I think I put my score wrong in my chart??
I personally don't think this level is even close to the worst ones. It wasn't even in my green doors list (which is why it has only been added in the update, and I heard the door doesn't actually work? lol)
EDIT: uhh, I think I put my score wrong in my chart??
Last edited by Koopster 7 years ago, edited 1 time in total.
- Voltgloss
- Ask, and you shall be given. Think, and you shall find.
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: 10 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
- Location: exploring the world, now with friends
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
I watched raocow's whole playthrough of Moontop Metonymy and I *still* don't understand what the message box was trying to convey about how to speed up the cloud. I also searched in vain for any actual metonymy.
- Zephyr_DragonLord
- The dragon awakens...!
- Posts: 1047
- Joined: 8 years ago
- First name: Zach
- Location: Somewhere between dreams and dormancy
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
I think it's a real roundabout way of saying that clouds transfer your airbound momentum into it, and by holding forward in the air in the right way, you can push the cloud forward. Also, it would be incredibly difficult to make the concept of metonymy within a level in the first place. I have never even heard of that word before now.Voltgloss wrote:I watched raocow's whole playthrough of Moontop Metonymy and I *still* don't understand what the message box was trying to convey about how to speed up the cloud. I also searched in vain for any actual metonymy.
But to clarify on my critique now that I have had time to think, this level is not a pile of garbage. Just deeply flawed to the point in which the good intent of the level can be deeply ruined. There are elements of good level design in there, such as the coin trails. But the level so blatantly ignores the horizontal limits of the Lakitu cloud that it alienates a good portion of the Mario-playing audience...
I am aware that this is a Vanilla Level Contest, but some levels work so much better with custom assets... This is one of those levels. So much so that I can see this level being in the top 30% of entries if it had the codes to make the cloud manually speed up, along with fixing those graphics on the cloud itself. Heck, it could reach the top 10 if those changes improved the other parts of the level. That's the degree to how much good controls matter; games live and die by how fluid the controls are. This is why some platformers feel so good to play; getting that feeling of responsiveness just right is not an easy task, but pays dividends.
I am prone to almost everything... except spontaneous violence.
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
(It was about time)
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
raocow wrote:I know there is a population on Earth. They like to populate. I like to gesticulate. We're friends!
(It was about time)
- morsel/morceau
- Posts: 401
- Joined: 14 years ago
- Location: exotic horse island
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
I have thought extensively about what this metonymy may be since I first played the level, and my best theory is: moontop = top of the moon = crust = effrontery = what Daizo had to have to make this level.Voltgloss wrote:I watched raocow's whole playthrough of Moontop Metonymy and I *still* don't understand what the message box was trying to convey about how to speed up the cloud. I also searched in vain for any actual metonymy.
dont wanna jihad no more
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
Really didn't enjoy this level. The way to speed up the cloud was painful IMO and barely even worked, and even though there's an explanation in the text box, it was pretty confusing. Even with the coin guides, it was occasionally unclear where to go. I never really managed to avoid the saw wall at the beginning either. It felt like this level was about finding the best two spots to tank hits and abusing the shortness of the level. Many obstacles were repeated more than necessary with little variation, too. This level is designed as if it is fast paced, but the sluggishness of the cloud really ruins that.
I still don't think it deserved worst world. I'm fine with the position it got.
I still don't think it deserved worst world. I'm fine with the position it got.
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
If I'm understanding it correctly I think it means that when you hold up+forward and tap jump it makes it so you jump and thus increase in speed but you almost immediately land back in the cloud which keeps that momentum temporarily so it boosts your cloud speed to higher than what it normally can manage. Seems like an extremely awkward mechanic to try and make use of though, especially in a hectic situation.Voltgloss wrote:I watched raocow's whole playthrough of Moontop Metonymy and I *still* don't understand what the message box was trying to convey about how to speed up the cloud. I also searched in vain for any actual metonymy.
- snoruntpyro
- cutest girl 2023
- Posts: 884
- Joined: 9 years ago
- Pronouns: she/her
- Contact:
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
Hey look it's my bad level!!!
This level is kind of a trainwreck. There's a lot of just random garbage thrown everywhere and it has the exact same aesthetic issues I complain about all the time (march 2016 me was even stupider). I regret not using those slide blocks more. I kinda just wasted what could have been a cool level.
I guess it was kinda rushed because my original level was kinda even worse, it was this gauntlet fortress thing, with even more just random ideas and not thought through design. I replaced it at the last second because I realized why it was bad.
I'm still salty over ninja boy's score tho because I guess short cave is a way better level
This level is kind of a trainwreck. There's a lot of just random garbage thrown everywhere and it has the exact same aesthetic issues I complain about all the time (march 2016 me was even stupider). I regret not using those slide blocks more. I kinda just wasted what could have been a cool level.
I guess it was kinda rushed because my original level was kinda even worse, it was this gauntlet fortress thing, with even more just random ideas and not thought through design. I replaced it at the last second because I realized why it was bad.
I'm still salty over ninja boy's score tho because I guess short cave is a way better level
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
46th: FISH IN SPACE!!!! by snoruntpyro
85th: HAUNTED WOODS by Gabriel Yanni
Pyro's level is one example of "overdecoration" that doesn't really hinder gameplay that much. I stand by thinking the level is pretty nice, but perhaps not a 47 in my metric lol
And the other level happened
85th: HAUNTED WOODS by Gabriel Yanni
Pyro's level is one example of "overdecoration" that doesn't really hinder gameplay that much. I stand by thinking the level is pretty nice, but perhaps not a 47 in my metric lol
And the other level happened
- Mata Hari
- Posts: 2523
- Joined: 14 years ago
- https://matahari.talkhaus.com/
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
Fish In Space is very much my kind of level because I am very much about putting enemies in inappropriate settings. It reminds me of the SMM level I made about underwater moles. Good times.
Re: VLDC9 - vendace lunacy discomposed copses 9
The fish level is cute and fun in the first half, but at the same time a bit confused as to what it's trying to do. More focus on the accelerator blocks would've been nice, because I found them to be the most enjoyable part of the level.
The cloud level would've worked fine in a hack where the cloud's speed was increased through hex editing or levelASM or something, but sadly, in a vanilla hack, Lakitu cloud levels are simply impossible to make fun. The cloud moves too slowly for Mario to successfully navigate through obstacles like that.
The cloud level would've worked fine in a hack where the cloud's speed was increased through hex editing or levelASM or something, but sadly, in a vanilla hack, Lakitu cloud levels are simply impossible to make fun. The cloud moves too slowly for Mario to successfully navigate through obstacles like that.
Re: VLDC9 - vendace lunacy discomposed copses 9
Fish in Space was a nice, relaxing level. It's one of those levels that manages to be fairly easy yet interesting and fun at the same time. I think the Fishing Boo was used fairly well, and the accelerator blocks were pretty cool. I would have preferred the first room to be extended with tougher obstacles with the accelerator blocks towards the second half of that room, and the third room to be cut out even though it was fun in its own right. Although more could have been done with the accelerator blocks, I still think the second room did a good job of making them less straightforward by throwing in "munchers" and scrolling. I also like this sort of aesthetic, despite some overdecoration.
The other level was a lot like a vanilla SMW level and it had — wait, everybody has already gone over this? I'll shut up now.
Weird how a world filled with castles doesn't end like one, unlike a lot of the other worlds.
The other level was a lot like a vanilla SMW level and it had — wait, everybody has already gone over this? I'll shut up now.
Weird how a world filled with castles doesn't end like one, unlike a lot of the other worlds.
- Zephyr_DragonLord
- The dragon awakens...!
- Posts: 1047
- Joined: 8 years ago
- First name: Zach
- Location: Somewhere between dreams and dormancy
Re: VLDC9 - vandalized liftoffs dangerous cruising 9
I feel like quoting you for some reason because I feel like I missed the boat and whatever.Pyro wrote:Hey look it's my bad level!!!
This level is kind of a trainwreck. There's a lot of just random garbage thrown everywhere and it has the exact same aesthetic issues I complain about all the time (march 2016 me was even stupider). I regret not using those slide blocks more. I kinda just wasted what could have been a cool level.
I guess it was kinda rushed because my original level was kinda even worse, it was this gauntlet fortress thing, with even more just random ideas and not thought through design. I replaced it at the last second because I realized why it was bad.
I'm still salty over ninja boy's score tho because I guess short cave is a way better level
Your level isn't bad at all. Fish in spaaaaace is a great and funny concept, and it was certainly realized here. Sure, there were things you could have done better, such as the water star section, but I really like the rest. You even made a Fishing Fish guy section I don't mind. And at least the rocks strewn on the ground have a purpose. The only other problem I have is that the golden stars paired with the water stars makes it a bit hard to concentrate, but it isn't neon flashing blue bad. I think you did good.
Haunted Woods has nice music, is a nice place, could have had a good gimmick and better dragon coins, and is overall nice. Yeah, it kind of happened, but there are ways to change that. These types of entries are the ones I like, though. It's better to blend in than to pop out in a rude manner. Some bad levels do that! How dare they... In a way, this level is just like Diddy Kong Racing... it ends as soon as it begins...
I am prone to almost everything... except spontaneous violence.
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
(It was about time)
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
raocow wrote:I know there is a population on Earth. They like to populate. I like to gesticulate. We're friends!
(It was about time)
- morsel/morceau
- Posts: 401
- Joined: 14 years ago
- Location: exotic horse island
Re: VLDC9 - vendace lunacy discomposed copses 9
These 'brown platforms floating on water' are often misunderstood. A common error is to continually jump on them when they are floating on lava, in the hope that this will prevent them from sinking (in fact it makes them sink further). A less common error (I've only seen it happen once) is to think that holding a shell makes you heavier and will help the platform sink further (in fact it doesn't).
The secret exit in Kuso Line is very obvious if you've seen the movie Sleepy Hollow (starring raocow as the voice of the horseman).
The secret exit in Kuso Line is very obvious if you've seen the movie Sleepy Hollow (starring raocow as the voice of the horseman).
dont wanna jihad no more
- Voltgloss
- Ask, and you shall be given. Think, and you shall find.
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: 10 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
- Location: exploring the world, now with friends
Re: VLDC9 - vendace lunacy discomposed copses 9
raocow was secretly Christopher Walken all this time? That explains a lot.