This thread exists now. Post favourite moments or something; I don't know.
Also, I'll just drop this silly diagram I made in MS Paint here, because it seems fitting for some reason. You'd have to zoom in quite a way to see it properly as it's all done pixelwise.
Key to initials:
2007
The Second Reality Project
Jikkyou Oshaberi Parodius
The Second Reality Project 2
Super Mario Infinity
Super Challenge World
Mario X World Deluxe
Mario X World Second Edition Returns
Super Mario World Plus 2
Super Mario World Plus
Super Mario World: The Master Courses
VIP2
VIP1
Mario X World: Bowser Strikes Back
Mario's Return
VIP3
(The Ninji Saga)
Rob-Omb's Quest
Super Mario Infinity 2
2008
Chaos CompleXX
Crash Man (and associates)
Luigi's Adventure
VIP4
Kamek's Revenge
Commander Keen: Marooned on Mars
Commander Keen 2: The Earth Explodes
Commander Keen 3: Keen Must Die
Commander Keen: Keen Dreams
Commander Keen 4: Secret of the Oracle
The Second Reality Project Reloaded
VIP1
VIP2
(Automaticon)
VIP3
Mario's Misadventure
Kouhai
Present Mario
Super Mario World: The Reture
VIP4
2009
Rise to the Challenge
Caramel Cave
Super Marisa World
Kouhai 2
Warning Forever
The Mario
MariAri
Luigi's World
World of Illusion
Mario Forever
The Laundromat
Super Mario World Returns
An Untitled Story
Super Mario World Returns 2
Random Week August '09
Super Mario World Returns Extra
Blob's Adventure 2
Super Challenge World
Super Metroid Legacy
Super Mario Omega
SMWCentral Choco Level Contest
Tottemo YEAHHHH!!
Mushroom Kingdom Meltdown
Super Time
A Mini Falafel Adventure
Runman
Mushroom Kingdom Meltdown 2
Nezumi Man
Super Mario World 2 +
2010
Random Week January '10
Scarlet Devil Mario
The Legend of Randorland 3
EVW
Deja Vu Tower
Hacks 101
A Super Mario Thing
SMWCentral Vanilla Contest '10
Kirby's Dream Land 3
VVVVVV
Let's Intermission with Mega Man X
/Mega Man X2
Bunny Must Die
Hack
Chelsea and the Seven Devils
The Second Reality Project 2
Hyper V
Spelunky
Newgrounds Roulette
(Winter WonDerp Land)
(Insert Coin)
Mario Gives Up
2011
An SMWCentral Production
Scarlet Devil Mario 2
(TheRealNinjaBoy's hack)
The Invasion 2
One More Level Weel
Megaman Rocks!
The Great Empire
Craz'd
Something
VIP5
Super Mario World FreedoMN
Swim Ikachan
Fantasy Explorer Nitroid
9th Door Contest
Mario Gives Up 2
Psycho Waluigi
Voxatron
Ascetic Super Mario World
2012
S. Mario
(YO'R GV(L)
Karoshi
GMC Jam 5
Mario Adventure
New! Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
(Facade)
Distorted Travesty
Vanilla Level Design Contest 5
Make A Good Level Contest
GMC Jam 6
Super Pixel Man +
Mega Man; A Day in the Limelight
(Contraste)
8 Powers
Super Talking Time Bros. 2
Bowser's Last Stand
Mega Man; A Day in the Limelight 2
Opening Pandora's Box
Copy Kitty
Super Talking Time Bros.
Romancing Mario
Distorted Travesty 2
MariAri 2
Yoshi's Island Level Design Contest
Drama Mistery
Notte Luminosa
Tower of Biased
VIP1
2013
(ROCMANX)
Street Fighter X Mega Man
Various GMC Jams
Copy Kitty: Cirnya
3000 Leagues in Search of Bowser
(GetYourEyesBack)
ViViD
(Just Blob)
Normal Super Mario Bros.
Kid Adventure
(Super Mario World Totally Legit Edition)
A Super Mario Bros. X Thing: Prelude to the Stupid
Copy Kitty: Kirby Comment Levels
Make a Good Level 2
Takkoman - Kouzatsu World
Apocalypse of Foroze
Super Marina World
Super Talking Time Bros. 2.5
Uirdz
Hina's Fluffy Dream
(Spheroids)
(No More Plumbers 2)
(a video on the internet about some games on the internet)
The Variety of Chance
(spooknorcopia)
Mega Man Rock Force
Hack 2
The Second Reality Project Reloaded
2014
Rockman 4-Infinity
Super Pika Land Ultra
Kid Adventure 2
(cat poke)
(let's double dragon 2 (??))
Make a Good Level X
Golden Yoshi Returns
Golden Yoshi Returns Again
Yoshi's Island: Forlorn Lands
(let's all things)
Copy Kitty Turbo
Mega Man Unlimited
A Second Mario Thing Base Rom
Yoshi's Island Level Design Contest '14
A Second Mario Bros. X Thing
Valdis Story
Superb Demo Sisters
Something Else
An Advent Christmas Thing
Stellar Swing
2
2015
Symphony of the Night
Vanilla Contest '14
Parodius Da!
Gokujou Parodius
(A Second Mario Thing (leftovers))
Super Mario Japan: Truth Story
Let's Cortex
Jikkyou Oshaberi Parodius
Super Meat Boy
Toadette Strikes
Super Mario World Remix
Vanilla Contest 8
Dragon (A Game about a Dragon)
My Garbage Cat Wakes Me UP at 3am Every Day
Shovel Knight
Sky Island
Soldexus
(Ashen Waste)
Kaizo Contest X
Jet Gunner
Make a Good Level X 2
StarTropics
Big Fish Legend
StarTropics 2: Zoda's Revenge
Wings of Vi
A Mini Falafel Adventure
Escape Goat
(Real Life Core)
Iji
An Advent Christmas X Thing
Mibibli's Quest
Mario Gives Up 3
Guacamelee!
2016
Shattered Lands
VIP2
Distorted Travesty 3
JUMP
HACK 3
Call of Cthulhu
The Hooray: Fishing Season
Drama Mistery 2
VIP3
Abducted Toad
Rex Rocket
Wario Land 4
Mega Man √-1
SMWCentral X
(Copy Kitty - Endless Mode)
Super Cat Planet
Kirby's Adventure
Super Mario Star Road
Mischief Makers
Make a Good Level 3
Hyper Princess Pitch
Make a Good Gift
Hyper Light Drifter
Donkey Kong '94
Vanilla Contest 9
2017
Dust: An Elysian Tail
Dynamite Headdy
Psychonauts
Off Camera
(an Uncle Broadsword thing)
ASPE
MegaMari
test.smc
Escape Goat 2
Hypnosis Redo
Rise to the Challenge
Shovel Knight: Plague of Shadows
Luigi's Adventure: Overseas Edition
Shovel Knight (challenge mode)
Mega Man X
things in brackets are one-video let's plays
The Second Reality Project
Jikkyou Oshaberi Parodius
The Second Reality Project 2
Super Mario Infinity
Super Challenge World
Mario X World Deluxe
Mario X World Second Edition Returns
Super Mario World Plus 2
Super Mario World Plus
Super Mario World: The Master Courses
VIP2
VIP1
Mario X World: Bowser Strikes Back
Mario's Return
VIP3
(The Ninji Saga)
Rob-Omb's Quest
Super Mario Infinity 2
2008
Chaos CompleXX
Crash Man (and associates)
Luigi's Adventure
VIP4
Kamek's Revenge
Commander Keen: Marooned on Mars
Commander Keen 2: The Earth Explodes
Commander Keen 3: Keen Must Die
Commander Keen: Keen Dreams
Commander Keen 4: Secret of the Oracle
The Second Reality Project Reloaded
VIP1
VIP2
(Automaticon)
VIP3
Mario's Misadventure
Kouhai
Present Mario
Super Mario World: The Reture
VIP4
2009
Rise to the Challenge
Caramel Cave
Super Marisa World
Kouhai 2
Warning Forever
The Mario
MariAri
Luigi's World
World of Illusion
Mario Forever
The Laundromat
Super Mario World Returns
An Untitled Story
Super Mario World Returns 2
Random Week August '09
Super Mario World Returns Extra
Blob's Adventure 2
Super Challenge World
Super Metroid Legacy
Super Mario Omega
SMWCentral Choco Level Contest
Tottemo YEAHHHH!!
Mushroom Kingdom Meltdown
Super Time
A Mini Falafel Adventure
Runman
Mushroom Kingdom Meltdown 2
Nezumi Man
Super Mario World 2 +
2010
Random Week January '10
Scarlet Devil Mario
The Legend of Randorland 3
EVW
Deja Vu Tower
Hacks 101
A Super Mario Thing
SMWCentral Vanilla Contest '10
Kirby's Dream Land 3
VVVVVV
Let's Intermission with Mega Man X
/Mega Man X2
Bunny Must Die
Hack
Chelsea and the Seven Devils
The Second Reality Project 2
Hyper V
Spelunky
Newgrounds Roulette
(Winter WonDerp Land)
(Insert Coin)
Mario Gives Up
2011
An SMWCentral Production
Scarlet Devil Mario 2
(TheRealNinjaBoy's hack)
The Invasion 2
One More Level Weel
Megaman Rocks!
The Great Empire
Craz'd
Something
VIP5
Super Mario World FreedoMN
Swim Ikachan
Fantasy Explorer Nitroid
9th Door Contest
Mario Gives Up 2
Psycho Waluigi
Voxatron
Ascetic Super Mario World
2012
S. Mario
(YO'R GV(L)
Karoshi
GMC Jam 5
Mario Adventure
New! Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
(Facade)
Distorted Travesty
Vanilla Level Design Contest 5
Make A Good Level Contest
GMC Jam 6
Super Pixel Man +
Mega Man; A Day in the Limelight
(Contraste)
8 Powers
Super Talking Time Bros. 2
Bowser's Last Stand
Mega Man; A Day in the Limelight 2
Opening Pandora's Box
Copy Kitty
Super Talking Time Bros.
Romancing Mario
Distorted Travesty 2
MariAri 2
Yoshi's Island Level Design Contest
Drama Mistery
Notte Luminosa
Tower of Biased
VIP1
2013
(ROCMANX)
Street Fighter X Mega Man
Various GMC Jams
Copy Kitty: Cirnya
3000 Leagues in Search of Bowser
(GetYourEyesBack)
ViViD
(Just Blob)
Normal Super Mario Bros.
Kid Adventure
(Super Mario World Totally Legit Edition)
A Super Mario Bros. X Thing: Prelude to the Stupid
Copy Kitty: Kirby Comment Levels
Make a Good Level 2
Takkoman - Kouzatsu World
Apocalypse of Foroze
Super Marina World
Super Talking Time Bros. 2.5
Uirdz
Hina's Fluffy Dream
(Spheroids)
(No More Plumbers 2)
(a video on the internet about some games on the internet)
The Variety of Chance
(spooknorcopia)
Mega Man Rock Force
Hack 2
The Second Reality Project Reloaded
2014
Rockman 4-Infinity
Super Pika Land Ultra
Kid Adventure 2
(cat poke)
(let's double dragon 2 (??))
Make a Good Level X
Golden Yoshi Returns
Golden Yoshi Returns Again
Yoshi's Island: Forlorn Lands
(let's all things)
Copy Kitty Turbo
Mega Man Unlimited
A Second Mario Thing Base Rom
Yoshi's Island Level Design Contest '14
A Second Mario Bros. X Thing
Valdis Story
Superb Demo Sisters
Something Else
An Advent Christmas Thing
Stellar Swing
2
2015
Symphony of the Night
Vanilla Contest '14
Parodius Da!
Gokujou Parodius
(A Second Mario Thing (leftovers))
Super Mario Japan: Truth Story
Let's Cortex
Jikkyou Oshaberi Parodius
Super Meat Boy
Toadette Strikes
Super Mario World Remix
Vanilla Contest 8
Dragon (A Game about a Dragon)
My Garbage Cat Wakes Me UP at 3am Every Day
Shovel Knight
Sky Island
Soldexus
(Ashen Waste)
Kaizo Contest X
Jet Gunner
Make a Good Level X 2
StarTropics
Big Fish Legend
StarTropics 2: Zoda's Revenge
Wings of Vi
A Mini Falafel Adventure
Escape Goat
(Real Life Core)
Iji
An Advent Christmas X Thing
Mibibli's Quest
Mario Gives Up 3
Guacamelee!
2016
Shattered Lands
VIP2
Distorted Travesty 3
JUMP
HACK 3
Call of Cthulhu
The Hooray: Fishing Season
Drama Mistery 2
VIP3
Abducted Toad
Rex Rocket
Wario Land 4
Mega Man √-1
SMWCentral X
(Copy Kitty - Endless Mode)
Super Cat Planet
Kirby's Adventure
Super Mario Star Road
Mischief Makers
Make a Good Level 3
Hyper Princess Pitch
Make a Good Gift
Hyper Light Drifter
Donkey Kong '94
Vanilla Contest 9
2017
Dust: An Elysian Tail
Dynamite Headdy
Psychonauts
Off Camera
(an Uncle Broadsword thing)
ASPE
MegaMari
test.smc
Escape Goat 2
Hypnosis Redo
Rise to the Challenge
Shovel Knight: Plague of Shadows
Luigi's Adventure: Overseas Edition
Shovel Knight (challenge mode)
Mega Man X
things in brackets are one-video let's plays