Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Performance Edition
- Voltgloss
- Ask, and you shall be given. Think, and you shall find.
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: 10 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
- Location: exploring the world, now with friends
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pseudolatry Edition
Mulling it over, I think the most insidious problem with this exit isn't the fog, but the ratchet scrolling. It's the ratchet scrolling that makes every slight mistake equal death and having to do the entire thing over again. If a slight mistake meant falling *part* of the way back, but not having to start *completely* over, the exit would I think become significantly more tolerable without losing the levelmaker's apparently intended "realistically climbing a mountain" effect.
I'm not saying that would be *enough* to make it work, but it's the single biggest change I think this needed.
I'm not saying that would be *enough* to make it work, but it's the single biggest change I think this needed.
-
- Posts: 27
- Joined: 7 years ago
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pseudolatry Edition
.
Last edited by hanayamata 7 years ago, edited 1 time in total.
- Super Maks 64
- Just your usual SMW hacker
- Posts: 361
- Joined: 7 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pseudolatry Edition
I'm going to be different and talk about the previous level.
Koopas kicking shells to hit On/Off blocks is something that works better than just timed blocks if the shells are visible and also the fact that Shellless Koopas were able to despawn so easily doesn't help. Enemies that throw a milion small fireballs that can pass through walls rarely work in a Mario hack (remember SMWCP?).
Also that desynced ExAnimation (it isn't hard to just use slots 0,8,10 and 18).
So this level.
Since I would be repeating everyone by pointing its flaws I'm gonna say that this level should've also had:
-a generator
-a seizure palette ExAnimation on the fog
-an UberASM that reverses your controls every five seconds
-Actually screw everything else and just make everything invisible so it isn't possible without Tools
7.8/100 Too many bad decisions
Koopas kicking shells to hit On/Off blocks is something that works better than just timed blocks if the shells are visible and also the fact that Shellless Koopas were able to despawn so easily doesn't help. Enemies that throw a milion small fireballs that can pass through walls rarely work in a Mario hack (remember SMWCP?).
Also that desynced ExAnimation (it isn't hard to just use slots 0,8,10 and 18).
So this level.
Since I would be repeating everyone by pointing its flaws I'm gonna say that this level should've also had:
-a generator
-a seizure palette ExAnimation on the fog
-an UberASM that reverses your controls every five seconds
-Actually screw everything else and just make everything invisible so it isn't possible without Tools
7.8/100 Too many bad decisions
- jayScribble
- FEEL THE FORCE
- Posts: 434
- Joined: 11 years ago
- Pronouns: it, they, that
- Location: Over there
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pseudolatry Edition
Still not enough bad things to add to this part of the level. You forgot:Super Maks 64 wrote: ↑7 years agoSince I would be repeating everyone by pointing its flaws I'm gonna say that this level should've also had:
-a generator
-a seizure palette ExAnimation on the fog
-an UberASM that reverses your controls every five seconds
-Actually screw everything else and just make everything invisible so it isn't possible without Tools
7.8/100 Too many bad decisions
- Autoscroll
- Powerup Filters
- Yoku/Disappearing-Reappearing Blocks
- Fishing Boo/Fishing Fish Guy
- Boo Cloud
- Boo Ceiling
- Munchers
Have a 3DS friend code and PM me if you added me: 1289-8788-1766
Three important threads for me:
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pseudolatry Edition
Frankly, I'm surprised nobody has made a "bad hack level BINGO card" and thrown these + the gimmicks in 2-3 on it just to see how long it takes us to find the ultimate terrible level and land a full card.jayScribble wrote: ↑7 years agoStill not enough bad things to add to this part of the level. You forgot:In all honesty, even two of the four gimmicks (Non-reverse scrolling, Icey floor, Wind, and the Fog) would be too much to handle.
- Autoscroll
- Powerup Filters
- Yoku/Disappearing-Reappearing Blocks
- Fishing Boo/Fishing Fish Guy
- Boo Cloud
- Boo Ceiling
- Munchers
- SAJewers
- ASMBXT Level Wrangler/A2XT Project Coordinator /AAT Level Designer
- Posts: 4200
- Joined: 11 years ago
- Location: Nova Scotia
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Propine Edition
Someone made a Bingo card for terrible video game tropes. Probably won't be hard to Fork the source code for a Bad Hacks Bingo card.
- morsel/morceau
- Posts: 401
- Joined: 14 years ago
- Location: exotic horse island
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Propine Edition
I just noticed the guy who made yesterday's well-received mountain climbing simulator was 660, the vip sprites, &c. graphics man. We have so much to thank him for. And I assume to-day's first level was made by SIG, since you can find several variants of the level among his 33 hacks.
dont wanna jihad no more
- Voltgloss
- Ask, and you shall be given. Think, and you shall find.
- Posts: 1147
- Joined: 10 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
- Location: exploring the world, now with friends
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Propine Edition
Yesterday's secret exit does not and should not diminish those accomplishments.morsel/morceau wrote: ↑7 years ago I just noticed the guy who made yesterday's well-received mountain climbing simulator was 660, the vip sprites, &c. graphics man. We have so much to thank him for.
Nor should those accomplishments redeem or excuse yesterday's secret exit.
I'm seeing a pattern in this hack of diminished visibility gimmicks and powerup starvation.
-
- Posts: 27
- Joined: 7 years ago
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Propine Edition
.
Last edited by hanayamata 7 years ago, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
... and that marks three of the "four annoying exits" done.
I agree with what raocow said at the end of the video 100%. Why the hell is there no midpoint? Yes, the level has a couple of other questionable design choices, but each of them would be so much more tolerable if you didn't have to restart from the very beginning every single time you die. It's just so annoying for no real reason, and it's such a shame too because the gimmick is actually super neat.
The level is a lot more tolerable if you just bring capes though, so there's that
The good news is that the rest of world two and the entirety of world three is a lore more enjoyable. Sure, there are some iffy spots here and there, but nothing nearly as bad as what we've seen in the last couple of videos. If everything goes well I'm pretty sure we'll see a comeback of happycow for the next while
I agree with what raocow said at the end of the video 100%. Why the hell is there no midpoint? Yes, the level has a couple of other questionable design choices, but each of them would be so much more tolerable if you didn't have to restart from the very beginning every single time you die. It's just so annoying for no real reason, and it's such a shame too because the gimmick is actually super neat.
The level is a lot more tolerable if you just bring capes though, so there's that
The good news is that the rest of world two and the entirety of world three is a lore more enjoyable. Sure, there are some iffy spots here and there, but nothing nearly as bad as what we've seen in the last couple of videos. If everything goes well I'm pretty sure we'll see a comeback of happycow for the next while
this is getting laundromatic
- Zephyr_DragonLord
- The dragon awakens...!
- Posts: 1047
- Joined: 8 years ago
- First name: Zach
- Location: Somewhere between dreams and dormancy
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
raocow had every right to complain; that second level was pretty flawed. His summary at the end of the video put it best, and I simply cannot improve on it.
The other level was good.
The other level was good.
I am prone to almost everything... except spontaneous violence.
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
(It was about time)
Any questions, concerns, or aspirations you have with me can go to the PM box... Now here's a quote:
raocow wrote:I know there is a population on Earth. They like to populate. I like to gesticulate. We're friends!
(It was about time)
- Super Maks 64
- Just your usual SMW hacker
- Posts: 361
- Joined: 7 years ago
- Pronouns: he/him/his
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
The Yoshi's Island's switch graphics are a VIP tradition and it was nice to see them in ASPE too (too bad the cement blocks are vanilla).
The switch level was neat with the blocks that set the state of the blocks and not toggle, although the light in the second part is questionable for me. The location of the switch isn't the most obvious thing when playing it for the first time I think.
The second level had some keysitting and two phantos that don't care about keys, and yeah it was kind of there.
It feels like someone forgot to change the mask files for the cloud blocks in THE SKY, also hey Lakitu. The music is rather unfitting.
raocow said everything I wanted to say about the second level in the video. One tile blind jumps and surprises plus no midpoint don't make the best experience.
Third switch aleady, huh. I expected that every world would have a switch and that the last one would have one very early.
BTW can Horikawa translate THE SKY into english, I didn't get what raocow said in the video about that level's name.
The switch level was neat with the blocks that set the state of the blocks and not toggle, although the light in the second part is questionable for me. The location of the switch isn't the most obvious thing when playing it for the first time I think.
The second level had some keysitting and two phantos that don't care about keys, and yeah it was kind of there.
It feels like someone forgot to change the mask files for the cloud blocks in THE SKY, also hey Lakitu. The music is rather unfitting.
raocow said everything I wanted to say about the second level in the video. One tile blind jumps and surprises plus no midpoint don't make the best experience.
Third switch aleady, huh. I expected that every world would have a switch and that the last one would have one very early.
BTW can Horikawa translate THE SKY into english, I didn't get what raocow said in the video about that level's name.
-
- Posts: 27
- Joined: 7 years ago
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
.
Last edited by hanayamata 7 years ago, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
of course the author didn't agree of adding a midpoint because MUH DIFFICULTY. World 2 has been a disaster so far with the unbalanced difficulty cruve. Why is Summit of the Gods and I Bought New Support Beams! in the same world as The Sky? It's a shame because there are some really nice levels in this hack but they are placed alongside levels where the author just takes things way too far. I thought 2-1 and SIG's level were both enjoyable.
I really hope raocow won't have to spend at least an hour on every level from here on out.
I really hope raocow won't have to spend at least an hour on every level from here on out.
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
That's really too bad, but there's nothing you could have done if that was the case. There were a few similar issues like that in JUMP, where a couple of people suggested changes, but you can't go against the explicit will of the author.hanayamata wrote: ↑7 years agoWe suggested adding a midpoint but in the end the author didn't seem to agree.
I feel like in the end the level still makes its point, the gimmick is very interesting and it's not like the entire level is completely irredeemable, there are some cool setups there as well.
It could have been so much better though
zagesaw wrote: ofc the author didn't agree of adding a midpoint because MUH DIFFICULTY. World 2 has been a disaster so far. Do they seriously have no concept of difficulty balance? Why is Summit of the Gods and I Bought New Support Beams! in the same world as The Sky? It's a shame because there are some really nice levels in this hack but they are placed alongside levels where the author just takes things way too far. I thought 2-1 and SIG's level were both enjoyable.
I disagree with this pretty strongly. If you only sort levels by difficulty you just end up with a completely unreasonable endgame with one long, hyper difficult level after another. By spreading them around the entire hack you give the player the ability to breathe, and they won't be burnt out as quickly
A lot of people have been questioning the difficulty curve of this hack, but I can't agree.
ASPE doesn't have a traditional difficulty curve that starts easy and gets gradually harder, but instead opts for a generally hard level of difficulty with a few easier and harder levels mixed in between. It's not what people are used to, but if you have a lot of very hard levels in your game it actually makes a lot of sense to do it that way. Putting them all at the end of the hack is not a good solution
I enjoy this type of difficulty balancing and in my opinion the ordering of the levels is actually one of the hack's strong points.
Calling the entirety of world two a "disaster" is also pretty hyperbolic. We have seen nine exits so far, out of which three were questionable.
I agree that that's not ideal, but it's not disastrous either
this is getting laundromatic
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
What you're getting here isn't that, though, what you're getting is a difficulty roller-coaster akin to the worst bits of JUMP.Ryrir wrote: ↑7 years ago
I disagree with this pretty strongly. If you only sort levels by difficulty you just end up with a completely unreasonable endgame with one long, hyper difficult level after another. By spreading them around the entire hack you give the player the ability to breathe, and they won't be burnt out as quickly
A lot of people have been questioning the difficulty curve of this hack, but I can't agree.
ASPE doesn't have a traditional difficulty curve that starts easy and gets gradually harder, but instead opts for a generally hard level of difficulty with a few easier and harder levels mixed in between. It's not what people are used to, but if you have a lot of very hard levels in your game it actually makes a lot of sense to do it that way. Putting them all at the end of the hack is not a good solution
I enjoy this type of difficulty balancing and in my opinion the ordering of the levels is actually one of the hack's strong points.
Calling the entirety of world two a "disaster" is also pretty hyperbolic. We have seen nine exits so far, out of which three were questionable.
I agree that that's not ideal, but it's not disastrous either
It's one thing to have breather levels in a hard game, but that doesn't even seem to be what they tried to do here.
Why don't you eat me?
I am perfectly tasty...
AND I'LL STEAL YOUR SOUL!
I am perfectly tasty...
AND I'LL STEAL YOUR SOUL!
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
I think my point will become clearer once we've actually seen the entire hack.
There are not a lot of levels like "THE SKY" in the game. The vast majority (something like approximately 75% of all levels) are just plain hard, and then you have a couple of ridiculous levels like Summit of the Gods as well.
If you'd order all these levels in a traditional difficulty curve, you'd get about half a world's worth of easy levels, then an enormous jump in difficulty, and maybe five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels at the very end.
That's not a very well balanced difficulty curve either, is it?
this is getting laundromatic
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
No, I suppose not.Ryrir wrote: ↑7 years agoI think my point will become clearer once we've actually seen the entire hack.
There are not a lot of levels like "THE SKY" in the game. The vast majority (something like approximately 75% of all levels) are just plain hard, and then you have a couple of ridiculous levels like Summit of the Gods as well.
If you'd order all these levels in a traditional difficulty curve, you'd get about half a world's worth of easy levels, then an enormous jump in difficulty, and maybe five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels at the very end.
That's not a very well balanced difficulty curve either, is it?
If it turns out you are right, then so it shall be.
For the moment, however, I remain a bit skeptical.
Why don't you eat me?
I am perfectly tasty...
AND I'LL STEAL YOUR SOUL!
I am perfectly tasty...
AND I'LL STEAL YOUR SOUL!
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
The only thing that the "Support Beam" level needed was some ice physics and it would have been perfect
- The Doctor
- Posts: 320
- Joined: 14 years ago
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
Ryrir wrote: ↑7 years ago If you'd order all these levels in a traditional difficulty curve, you'd get about half a world's worth of easy levels, then an enormous jump in difficulty, and maybe five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels at the very end.
That's not a very well balanced difficulty curve either, is it?
The ideal difficulty curve is a game that gets steadily harder as it goes on, but has breather levels to give the player a rest in between the rage-inducing levels. I'd say those five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels should be spread out in the second half of the game (none in the first two worlds) with some easier (relatively speaking) levels in between them. The problem is that world 2 -- the early game I remind you -- put three extremely hard levels back to back to back. Sorry, but I just can't agree with you that this is good design. Here's a cool graph I found online that I think shows the perfect difficulty curve.
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
Sure there's a way to deal with that. Threaten to not include the level at all! If the author is being stubborn like that.Ryrir wrote: ↑7 years agoThat's really too bad, but there's nothing you could have done if that was the case. There were a few similar issues like that in JUMP, where a couple of people suggested changes, but you can't go against the explicit will of the author.hanayamata wrote: ↑7 years agoWe suggested adding a midpoint but in the end the author didn't seem to agree.
-Banned in Antarctica
Official raocow subscriber # 30,000Sebby19 wrote:If your life depends on throwing up, switch to the keyboard
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
Or just be upfront at the start and say that the project heads hold permission to edit your levels for quality of life reasonsSebby19 wrote: ↑7 years agoSure there's a way to deal with that. Threaten to not include the level at all! If the author is being stubborn like that.Ryrir wrote: ↑7 years agoThat's really too bad, but there's nothing you could have done if that was the case. There were a few similar issues like that in JUMP, where a couple of people suggested changes, but you can't go against the explicit will of the author.hanayamata wrote: ↑7 years agoWe suggested adding a midpoint but in the end the author didn't seem to agree.
Re: Super ASPE Mario - All Stars Pillar Edition
The problem is that you're assuming that world two is early game, when it's really, really not. The hack only has four worlds, and the fourth world has fewer levels than any other world as well, which makes world two decidedly mid-game.The Doctor wrote: ↑7 years agoRyrir wrote: ↑7 years ago If you'd order all these levels in a traditional difficulty curve, you'd get about half a world's worth of easy levels, then an enormous jump in difficulty, and maybe five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels at the very end.
That's not a very well balanced difficulty curve either, is it?
The ideal difficulty curve is a game that gets steadily harder as it goes on, but has breather levels to give the player a rest in between the rage-inducing levels. I'd say those five super ridiculous, rage-inducing levels should be spread out in the second half of the game (none in the first two worlds) with some easier (relatively speaking) levels in between them. The problem is that world 2 -- the early game I remind you -- put three extremely hard levels back to back to back. Sorry, but I just can't agree with you that this is good design. Here's a cool graph I found online that I think shows the perfect difficulty curve.
Another point that I feel like you're missing is that the difficulty threshold was high from the very start of the game. The second level of the game was already difficult, levels like "This Stage" were difficult and even stuff that raocow breezed through, like "EXPRESS" or getting all the dragon coins in "R Lake" are not trivial either.
From that level of difficulty the step up to "Underground Exploration" is not that high. If you consider the secret exit of "Summit of the Gods" to be bonus content, that level doesn't even factor into the equation. I guess you could argue that "Support Beams" should have been placed somewhere else on the map to give a break after "Underground Exploration", but that's basically it.
From my point of view the game actually follows your graph pretty well (:
I am pretty sure that the development of the hack didn't work that way. Maybe hanaymata can correct me on this, but my assumption is that there weren't any project leaders at all. People just submitted their levels, some peeps stepped up to do the overworld and that was that.
Of course the level authors might have given each other criticism, but if that other author explicitly doesn't agree to these changes, who are you as just another level designer to decide that their work should not be included in the final product?
this is getting laundromatic